@ScoutingDad posted:@Genemed Turntables are cool but require a lot of compromise.
I am not sure you are gaining a whole lot with the change. It looks like you can get 2 maybe 3 cars on each spur. I count 7 spurs on each design. You could fit in an extra spur on top of the red spur for 8 on the TT version. If you proceed with this version make sure you put in a run around so an engine can back into the spur and depart. You have spurs going opposite directions meaning one engine would not be able to get out of the spur. The run around enables the engine at the head to pull in, uncouple and exit the track, then come in from behind to finish the job. There are a couple of places to do this, maybe just connect to the same red spur.
In my build I ended up using Ross curved switches in order to get a decent amount of yard space in my 7 track yard. They save a huge amount of linear space.
Thank you, it all makes perfect sense in a realistic train world. As I mentioned to Bob in the previous post, there isn’t much realism in running my layout. All I’m looking for is room for a couple pieces of rolling stock so an engine can back into the siding, uncouple and move on or stay there. Not realistic or prototypical but it’s simple and works for me. If I ever designed a new layout, it would have what you’re mentioning.
Thanks again for your advice, Gene