Skip to main content

so, after 18 months of experimentation, trial and error, I’ve developed some definite favourites from amongst my collection. In no particular order, they are;

1) Lionel “Polar Express” 2-8-4. Basically a traditional size, traditional style loco with a whistle tender and can motor. Robust, pulls reasonably well, totally reliable, a nice piece.

2) Williams die-cast Scale Hudson. Big, sure-footed thing with lots of pulling power, will walk away with 5 carriages (belying its reputation as an uncontrollable rocket ship, although it definitely IS fast if that’s what you want. Terrifying whistle. Another “PreWar reborn” loco and none the worse for it.

3) MTH K4s, with PS1 replaced by modern electronics. I just like this; scale size, nicely detailed, looks the part. I was always going to have a K4s, and here it is.

4) Williams brass USRA Pacific. Just a nice, simple, “period” brass loco. Didn’t cost much, a whistle would be nice...

5) Lionel 24xx carriages, now upgraded with LED lights. Just a thoroughly nice set.

6) Lionel 1992 TCA extruded carriages, 5 in all. I was always going to have a dome car!



What are others’ favourites?

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

On my fleet currently, I'd say:

230: My first engine, reliable, bought cheap, and runs great.

681: Great puller, heavy weight, runs great, looks great.

2055: My first hudson, reliable and reminds me of the people I helped when their father died and left them his collection.

1615: Excellent puller, and while not the cleanest looking, one of my most reliable engines on the fleet.

240: Runs great, has a extremely interesting story behind it, looks just like day one.

624: Clean, reliable, good puller, sounds almost like the real thing when bogged down.

Marx 333: Looks amazing!

Marx 81: I love the paint.

Marx M100005: Looks great.

Rolling stock wise:

Silver Series Cars: Look amazing.

Minute Man Car: One of my grandpa's favorites, one of my first cars.

2472: Looks great, love it behind my pennsy-style engines.

All the SP cabooses: They're just so iconic for postwar.

All the Cranes: They're just fun.

Last edited by Kent Locomotive Works

My favorite items, at least for now are:

Locomotives:

1. MTH E8's, I have four, with my favorite being the Rock Island Bicentennial Unit.

2. MTH Rock Island SD40-2

3. Any GP7/9, specifically modern Lionel and MTH.

4. Marx 666 and 1666 2-4-2's, I love the smell of ozone!

Freight Cars:

1. Atlas PS-2 4750 Covered Hoppers, I have a bunch

2. Weaver PS-2 4740 Covered Hoppers, I have a bunch

3. Atlas PS-2 4427 Covered Hoppers, see a theme.

4. Steel Side Reefers, specifically Packing House related. I spent 20 years designing meat packing equipment so I have a soft spot for these. Plus I really enjoy building the Intermountain cars.

This is a tough one.  Favorite items? I guess at the moment:

  • Always Scale length GG1s. Up to 17 now.
  • A kitbashed 1950's brass CNJ 10 wheeler CNJ Camelback in 2 rail.
  • About 10 All-Nation 64' CNJ style coach kits in various states of completion.
  • 3rd Rail FP7s in 2 rail. 
  • PSC P70r and P70r Coach-Broiler in 2 rail.
  • 3rd Rail ATSF E6 A-B set / Burlington E5a in 3 rail.
  • GGD El Capitan Sets in ATSF and Amtrak in 3 rail.
  • GGD Canadian in VIA Rail in three rail.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×