Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

As a long time 2 railer I believe these are the best to scale freight cars Lionel has ever produced, despite having to shorten their container length to accommodate typical 3 rail radii [1/2"] and corresponding side lettering , as is typical of the 3 rail Mfgs not all road names are accurate for these particular cars, the cars are very well done exceeding the current Atlas Maxi stacks in most areas. The ACF centerflows were also quite nice. In recent years Lionel has not done cars this good. I think this diecasting process is getting too expensive for  the production today.JMO See examples with correct containers, 20', 40' and 45'.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Lionel Husky Stacks 002
  • Lionel Husky Stacks 001
Last edited by hibar
hibar posted:

As a long time 2 railer I believe these are the best to scale freight cars Lionel has ever produced, despite having to shorten their container length to accommodate typical 3 rail radii [1/2"] and corresponding side lettering , as is typical of the 3 rail Mfgs not all road names are accurate for these particular cars, the cars are very well done exceeding the current Atlas Maxi stacks in some areas.

These Lionel cars are excellent. (Not sure why they were made short, clearly not a car for O27!)

hibar posted:

As a long time 2 railer I believe these are the best to scale freight cars Lionel has ever produced, despite having to shorten their container length to accommodate typical 3 rail radii [1/2"] and corresponding side lettering , as is typical of the 3 rail Mfgs not all road names are accurate for these particular cars, the cars are very well done exceeding the current Atlas Maxi stacks in some areas. The ACF centerflows were also quite nice. In recent years Lionel has not done cars this good. I think this diecasting process is getting too expensive for  the production today.JMO

Yes I agree the detail is astounding. Definitely a great buy if you can find them nib.

Back in 2007-8 they were all over I was buying 2 packs for 90-100 from dealers happy to move them, I suspect Lionel made substantial runs back then, last retail pricing started to get up there and they have not been offered since.

BobbyD posted:
hibar posted:

As a long time 2 railer I believe these are the best to scale freight cars Lionel has ever produced, despite having to shorten their container length to accommodate typical 3 rail radii [1/2"] and corresponding side lettering , as is typical of the 3 rail Mfgs not all road names are accurate for these particular cars, the cars are very well done exceeding the current Atlas Maxi stacks in some areas.

These Lionel cars are excellent. (Not sure why they were made short, clearly not a car for O27!)

The cars themselves are accurate length to prototype, slightly wider but interior bulkheads were moved in to allow truck swing with cookie cutter wheel sets for 0-31 curves, requiring containers also well detailed to be 1/2" short [2 scale ft] compare to MTH 48' containers which will not fit in wells. This subject has had considerable discussion in previous postings. Just saying!

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×