Skip to main content

A while back I purchased a NIB 16 year old MTH GP-40.  20-2420-1.

It was a PS2 model. To my dismay within the first few days the PS2 system gave up the "magic smoke" and it was then dead as a door nail. Sitting still it blew 8A inline fuses to the track.

Repair/upgrade to PS3 estimates were around $300.00 and I chose not to spend that kind of $$. Since I do not own an MTH DCS system and only ran the engine conventionally anyway I decide to gut it and install a Williams electronic E-unit #00247 so the engine could be run in a conventional manner. The motors are wired in series and they run fine.

That all went well. I and my electronically inclined friend had a bit of a go at getting the lighting correct but finally solved all the wiring issues. All work as originally designed.

So... about the smoke unit. It has a pair of working 16 Ohm resistors (netting 8 Ohms) that function correctly. The smoke fan motor was noisy but  I removed the impeller, added one drop of light oil to the top bearing and then it was fine. The smoke fan motor works. The wick in the smoke chamber was completely dry (16 years old) so I wet it with about 30 drops of MTH smoke fluid directly before closing up the chamber. I noticed that the smoke wick was installed between the resistors. Is this correct? Or should it be loosely packed into the chamber and then have the resistors sit on top of it?

Anyway the smoke does work but only tepidly. I had read on the forum that the smoke unit heater needed 5 VDC and that's what it's getting. The motor is being supplied with 3 VDC. With conventional operation at slow speed sometimes the AC track voltage is low. I think that has some effect on the voltage to the heater. The smoke on/off switch is correctly hooked up and it works.

I was thinking of adding a buck/boost regulator to up the heater voltage but don't want to ruin anything as the engine runs good now. I need to know what might be a maximum DC voltage supplied to the heater to get good smoke. I could put the buck/boost regulator in the fuel tank. There's room next to the speaker for it.

Does anyone have some suggestions as to getting good smoke output with this unit?

Also is there any value to the old PS2 guts? I've been told that the sound card is good but have no way to test that.

I'm including some pictures of the install. It's nearly as crowded in there as when the PS2 was installed.DSCN1462DSCN1463DSCN1464DSCN1465DSCN1467DSCN1468DSCN1475

Mark

Attachments

Images (7)
  • DSCN1462
  • DSCN1463
  • DSCN1464
  • DSCN1465
  • DSCN1467
  • DSCN1468
  • DSCN1475
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

 there are 3 different voltages on the ps 2 boards that the remote controls. low medium and high setting depending what level of smoke you want! don't remember what  the voltages are maybe 6 or 8 but  I'm  sure a asc tech on here will chime in soon ! is is either a voltage issue or you need to replace the wick and maybe even the heater resister!

 

The wick indeed is captured between the resistors in a standard PS/2 smoke unit.  You want about 6-7 watts in the smoke unit for good smoke, for conventional operation you'll have difficulty getting that with variable voltage on the track.  When I bench test them, I find that 6 volts DC on the smoke resistors smokes pretty well with those units.  Note that you need a MAXIMUM of 5V on the smoke fan motor, running above that will greatly shorten it's life.

I doubt the board is useful to anyone, that's the old 5V board, and if it's blowing fuses on power-up, it's very unlikely it can be fixed for any reasonable price.

Heater power (Watts) = Voltage x Voltage / Resistance.  So doing the math, if an 8 Ohms heater, and want 6-7 Watts as GRJ suggests, Voltage = 6.9-7.5 Volts.

The PS2 electronics came in 2 versions.  As GRJ says you have so-called 5V version which used a 9V-size battery.  The electronics was in effect an integral single-piece unit and difficult to troubleshoot-repair.  The later PS2 version (so-called 3V version) could be separated into two boards.  IF you had this version, there might be some "scrap" value as this version was easier to work with.  This might be where you picked up the idea that just the "sound" board (vs. "power" board) has residual value.

Last edited by stan2004

Be advised your link is to a "boost" regulator as opposed to a 'true' buck-boost regulator.  I hesitate to make hand-waving generalities, but if you apply say, 12V to a typical "boost" regulator set to 7V output, you will get an output closer to 12V than 7V.  A boost-only regulator does not have to ability to regulate the output voltage when the incoming voltage is greater than the target.

Another observation.  I can't quite tell the size of your smoke on-off slide switch.  But those "micro" slide switches don't have much current-carrying capacity (typically much less than an Amp).  In the MTH PS2/3 engines those switches carry only mA of current because this switch is only talks to the microprocessor to tell it to turn the smoke on/off - hence negligible current flow through the switch.  But as I understand your implementation, you're running all the smoke circuit power thru that switch (?) in which case it might be carrying over an Amp of current.  

 

Last edited by stan2004
banjoflyer posted:
Chris Lonero posted:

It’s water under the bridge at this point but did you put a new charged battery in the engine before you ran it on the track? 

Well not knowing any better when I first put it on the track I powered it up and waited about 30 seconds to press the DIR  button on my TMCC Cab1. It took a few tries but it eventually did run. Then I posted that scenario on the forum and found out about the "white battery of death". I replaced it with a BCR. Then all ran fine. For a few days.  Then it went kaput. Bad luck? Probably.

Maybe the white battery starts killed it. Maybe not. Like you said, "It’s water under the bridge".

mark

It did happen to me once! Any MTH engine especially PS-1 or PS-2 with a 5 volt board needs to have a new charged green battery or a new BCR before putting any voltage to it. The engine was new but unfortunately the battery was 16 years old.    Live and learn. 

Last edited by Chris Lonero
banjoflyer posted:
 
...Hopefully a unit like this will start putting out the 7VDC for the heater at low track AC voltage. 

Another observation about the latest buck-boost module.  Under Precautions, it says:

6. The module has input undervoltage protection function, the default is about 4.2V, below this value, it will automatically disconnect the output, to re-power the module can be restored (note that the module port voltage, when the input current is relatively large , Do not ignore the input voltage on the wire).

Like most DC-DC converter modules on eBay, this one has what appears to be a relatively small onboard input capacitor...it is expecting "smooth" DC from a battery or whatever.  But in this case you have AC thru a bridge.  The point being there will be ripple on your DC input to the converter and if it dips below the ~4.2V UVP threshold, the converter might essentially shut down up to 120 times per sec at low track AC voltage. Converters like this generally have a start-up sequence that can confound matters.  In other words even if you measure 5V DC (average) with a meter at the input, with the ripple from AC-to-DC conversion you might be starving the converter.

You may already have a large filter capacitor which will help low-voltage performance.  But if performance is flakey, try adding capacitance on the input - I'm talking hundreds (plural) of uF.

Last edited by stan2004

The buck/boost regulators normally have two inductors.  When I look up the XL6009 data sheet, they're pretty slippery as to if that circuit will really do the wide range buck/boost.

XL6009 Data Sheet

eBay: 142513059285 looks to be one that truly clearly states it's capabilities, and it also has two inductors, one of the key indicators that I've seen for working buck/boost designs.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • mceclip0
banjoflyer posted:

 

...Also my buddy appreciated Stan's observation about the slide switch carrying excessive current. He is going to change the set-up so that the slide switch only turns on/off an added relay or (mosfet?)  that will control the flow of power to the smoke unit. 

In general, most of these DC-DC converters have a magic regulator IC chip.  If you use one based on the XL6009 note that one of its 5 pins is "ENABLE".  This allows on/off control with a low-current control signal.  So you should not need an external added relay or transistor.  Obviously you'd need to tack in a wire.

Untitled

 

 

 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Untitled

If the spec's can be believed, it should do fine.  I actually have a very similar module, looks to be the same layout with slightly different inductors.  When I bench tested these, they did indeed to the buck/boost over a wide range. 

Note that you need a DC source, so a bridge and probably additional capacitance will be needed, I'd start with at least an extra 470uf, and preferably around 1,000uf at 35V.

Last edited by gunrunnerjohn

Let me know if you want to consider a cheap horn/bell board, I might be able to fix you up.

Hi John -- I know I'm 2 years late to the party....



I have 2 requests for you:

1. Do you still have these cheap sound (whistle/bell) boards? If so, what would be the price mailed to 43068?

2. In other threads you said that you had upgraded couplers on many K-Line locos over the years, and had stock couplers. I have a K-2200-8 S2 switcher. Do you have the coupler for that? If so, what is the price?

Thanks.

Bill

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×