Skip to main content

"HONGZ" stands for HO scale, N scale, G scale, and Z scale.

Post your non-O scale stuff here!

As posted elsewhere, I recently bought a Bachmann Super Chief Ready-to-Run N scale train set as a little present for myself.  Here are my thoughts and some pictures.  The set caught my eye when I stumbled upon it while researching prices for a used O scale Lionel 44-ton switcher (which I also bought).  I've always liked the western railroads but they fall outside my two modeling locations (PA and MA).  And, an EMD F-series engine has been on my wish list for a while.  Next thing I knew, the Sante Fe set was calling my name loudly and clearly.  Walmart offered the set at the best price along with free shipping -- and, well, I really earned a new toy and deserved some play time after 12 days of solving elder care challenges across two states! That's my story and I'm sticking with it ...

Meanwhile, I started wondering whether I could use this N set as a cheaper and space saving alternative to giving in and purchasing O scale Northeastern-based trains/cars that aren't part of my modeling era and railroad focus and for which I have absolutely no storage space.  So, before the set even arrived, I bought three 50' boxcars on sale from ModelTrainStuff: an Atlas Delaware & Hudson, a Micro-Trains Bangor and Aroostook, and a Bachmann Providence and Worcester -- all for less than the price of an O scale boxcar.  Was I going to be tempted to the "small side" or was I just really congratulating myself on surviving a "job well done"?

As is typical of ordering from Walmart online, the set arrived early.  What a breeze to set up! This experience validates my whining about the annoying lack of precision for much of the O gauge track and switches that I buy.  Yes, they are toys but at the larger size, I expect clean meeting points and joints but often find myself filing, bending, or getting a bit miffed (only the first two strategies work 'though :-).  But not with this Bachmann set.  At the smaller size, precision is critical; without it, the train won't run. I was able to get the train up and running without once touching a file, a pair of pliers or a Dremel tool -- a first. YEAH!!!  Another nice thing was that the instruction manual was actually written for this particular consist, not the generic or incorrect instructions that can come with O scale sets or engines.

The train runs smoothly and I especially like the fine control over speeds at the lower end.  The slower speed is quite meditative but the higher speeds (half way on the controls) make me dizzy given the small 24" or so diameter track.  The ad copy said it came with straight track, but it doesn't. I can imagine this scale being used for long stretches of desert landscape.  The consist is nice.  It seems that sets typically mix and match car eras or railroad lines in a way that is visually appealing but not necessarily prototypical (like those darn cabooses with the round windows).  While I didn't research the actual car bodies for era and accuracy, the build dates stamped on them and the RR lines included made sense for a Sante Fe train.  So I give Bachmann an added bonus for "consistency".  Get it?

The only negative so far is one set of wheels keeps falling off the Atlas D&H.  They look to be plastic so it's not surprising.

Bottom line: I'm enjoying this set, but no, I'm not giving up on O.  Bigger is better when it comes to my trains. But I may consider using this scale to manage the expense and tame the urge to buy more O scale stuff out of my modeling era or railroads for which I really don't have any room.  And then there this: an N scale yellow UP diesel with the flag on the side would look really awesome in my curio cabinet next to my UP etched shot glass and railroad butter pat collection :-}.

Here are some pix. Enjoy! (More later on my inspiration for a below-ceiling shelf layout.)

Tomlinson Run Railroad

 

 

 

 

Attachments

Images (7)
  • aaSuperChief: Bachmann N Scale Super Chief Ready-to-Run Set
  • aTheBachmanSuperChiefRTRSetinN: The consist
  • b-F7-A-on-the-PaintedDesert: Out-of-focus F7-A and "Painted Desert"
  • cBangorandAroostook: Micro-Trains 50' Bangor and Aroostook (door opens)
  • HidinginPlainSight: How to Hide a 50' Box Car in Plain Sight
  • cDelwareandHudson: Atlas 50' Delaware and Hudson
  • dProvidenceandWorcester: Bachmann Providence and Worcester (door opens)
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Here are photos of a few more N scale purchases divided into Eastern and Western railroads. Since my initial post, I picked up two Bachmann switches and a little more track just to play with.  I like the feature whereby you can snap the switch controls together so you only need one accessory wire. However, the switches tend to make the F3 derail. But the lovely Kato EMD SD70ACe in UP flag livery that I am enjoying is longer and so can handle the switches without incident.  In keeping with using this scale to buy affordable and space saving versions of railroads that I like but aren't part of my two modeling eras, I picked up a Bachmann Maine Central boxcar and steel caboose, and a Delaware & Hudson prototypical caboose.  So far, I haven't found the correct B&M motive power but I was interested to learn that D&H engines (from my college days) went through my current area all the way up to Maine.  It's nice when the collection "ties" together unexpectedly like that.

It's still fun to run these little trains but at least one other car has suffered from plastic wheels popping off. This is definitely NOT a gauge for running at night on the floor with poor lighting as the cars often derail depending on the car order and couplers in use.  It's back to my O gauge when I'm not in the mood for delicate operations.

Lastly, I decided that the Sante Fe Bachmann caboose that came with the ready to run set really needed window glass, so I cut out and glued some clear plastic taken from a sushi take out lid.  It worked surprisingly well but I can't seem to get a decent close-up.

TRRR

Attachments

Images (2)
  • East: New Maine Central and D&H
  • West: New UP
Last edited by TomlinsonRunRR
PRR1950 posted:

Just a comment about "set consistency" you mentioned in your first post.  No Santa Fe F unit would ever have pulled a BN painted gondola.  The F units were history way before BN came into being.

Chuck

Thanks, Chuck. After my initial post I managed to do some fallen flag research on wikipedia to further hone my understanding. As a northeasterner, it's interesting learning about the western RRs.  They seem to have some of the best paint jobs, too!

Rusty, that's so true about color and eye appeal choices for any of these sets.  That was my pretty much point: that considering that cars were chosen from a marketing perspecrive, Bachmann did a decent job in creating a consist compared to other sets I've purchased where the eras and RRs represented by the cars seem to come out of fantasy land with some heavy time travel thrown in :-).  It's the historian in me; I care about these things -- when I have time to do the research, that is.

Tomlinson Run RR

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×