Skip to main content

I just received the C&NW Poultry car (Lionel) and I was disappointed to find that  it was

 not Illuminated.  To my Knowledge, this is the first poultry car not to have lights.  For the

price, I would have expected lights.  Even the picture makes it look illuminated.  Fool me

once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.  There won't be a second time!

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

The original postwar poultry cars, 3434 operating and 6434 non-operating poultry cars were illuminated, I believe they each had two bulbs.

The car has been reissued a number of times in the Modern era, I don't know the characteristics of those cars.
Out of curiosity, I looked up the car that is the subject of this thread. The catalog does not say it is illuminated.

Originally Posted by Martin H:

I have to admit I know nothing about the prototype for this, so here I go with a silly question:

 

Why should a poultry car be lighted?  I mean, cabooses are lit because we understand that humans inhabited them.  Why would chickens need a light?

Yep..those chicken coops ( or at least many of them) were illuminated at night,,no time off from egg laying. No coffee breaks either.

Originally Posted by cbojanower:

If this is the 6-26495 Poultry car you might want to go read the catalog description, it clearly says in the description "Non-operating version" and doesn't mention lights at all,  so I wouldn't expect any lights.

 

No harm, no fowl 

 

The "Non-operating version" as in No Sweeper not no lights.  It seems as though

the Thanksgiving Non-operating poultry car does come with lights.

I guess now you know it cost $10.00 to light up a car. I am not saying its right or wrong that they did this, but I wouldn't be surprised that it didn't have the same features as the T-Day car because.

 

1) Cheaper than the other car.

2) No roller pickup was shown in the illustration.

 

They were probably trying to make a price point and I guess the light was it. Now if they said it had a light and they pulled it, it would have been different

 

I believe any O gauge car that has illumination is a plus, especially when running with the lights out or at night.  Illuminated cars seem to draw the interest of young and old alike when operating on a layout or around the Christmas tree.

 

I would upgrade the car with pick-up truck and led light and beware of item descriptions in catalogs no mater which manufacturer it is from.

 

To Martin, illuminated cars and other cars that may have an animated function while operating are for entertainment purposes of the operator and viewers. 

 

TEX

Steve

Originally Posted by pennsydave:

I just bought a USMC bunk car(6-5727) at auction and there is no USMC on it anywhere except on the box label!!    I figure it's the stealth version.  Maybe the poultry car is destined for a secret military base and you can't have lights to give away it's location.  

You may be right.  When I was in the Army there were some who resembled Poultry parts.

Last edited by Grampstrains
Originally Posted by kanawha:
Originally Posted by Martin H:

 

 

Why should a poultry car be lighted?  I mean, cabooses are lit because we understand that humans inhabited them.  Why would chickens need a light?

To keep them warm???

 

Ken

To get to the other side.  And, really, isn't it about time we stopped questioning chickens' motives?

Originally Posted by Chuck Sartor:

I would imagine the car would have had kerosene heaters and an attendant. Maybe a couple of kerosene lanterns. So it may have looked illuminated a little.

A gallant attempt to try to inject some genuinely useful information into this thread, an effort which unfortunately appears to be wasted on this crowd.

Bob

 

Originally Posted by Jim 1939:

If the catalog said non-operating, I think that sums it up.

Don't blame Lionel cause you didn't read the description.

We all agree it would have been a nicer car with lights. So add them.

 

You haven't ever heard Lionel call their illuminated passenger cars as "operating" do you?  I recall that Lionel has always called their cars that had interior lighting as illuminated, not operating. 

 

Cars that would be classified as operating would have some mechanical animation to them, like the ducking brakeman car, the poultry car (with the sweeper guy) and the milk car with the milkman that moves (throws) the milk canisters out the door.

 

 

Originally Posted by John Korling:
 
"You haven't ever heard Lionel call their illuminated passenger cars as "operating" do you?  I recall that Lionel has always called their cars that had interior lighting as illuminated, not operating."
 
Not for nothing but I don't think the description says illuminated either.
 
Besides, why would you want chickens to lay eggs in a train car?
Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×