This panoramic photo, taken by H.V.Campell in 1938, shows part of a steel mill located in my hometown, Duquesne, PA. That river is the Monongahela. I lived my childhood in a house up on that hill (not built yet at the taking of this photo, well before my birth). We could hear those trains shuffling up and down those tracks all day and night, especially during the time when steam locomotives still dominated.
My strongest impression of steel mills in the greater Pittsburgh area was one of SIZE = huge proportions. Even the hand-tools were big!
For example, take special note of the length and breadth of those curves of track(s), and the radii involved. And the long, long lines of coal hoppers. Can you discern how many cars are in those consists? Could we ever have that number and length of RR tracks of cars like that on a layout ? !
And take special note of the part of the steel mill in this photo and in my cropping of it, included. Those structures are only a segment of the steel production at this plant. The furnaces are not even within this photo. They are just beyond the frame, off to the left of the shot.
Having grown up exploring and playing and finally working in this environment, when I hear talk of "scale curves" on a layout, I don't even know what that means. Of course, we have to have our model trains turn around on any given platform. But "scale" curves? Not possible, IMHO. Not practical. Not do-able.
And crafting a steel mill suggests to me - no matter what the scale, O, HO, N, or even Z - a considerable accommodation and "foreshortening," a compacting, of all modeling elements for the space available. Anyone who insists on true-to-scale "rivet-counting," esp. if you have a layout, or are planning one, needs to lighten-up. And get real (or as close as we can get to "real" scale modeling.)
What is your perspective on this? How do our model railroads actually satisfy any prospective scale approach to real railroading?
I think that is why I found myself giving so much attention, energy, experimentation, and learning (crafting) to augment my trains with realistic (?) looking scenery. At least the scenery can tell the truth, or at least, an attempt at it.
What do you say about it being impossible to make a layout truly to-scale of any railroad panorama?
FrankM.