One thing that has been consistent in my many acquisitions and turnovers was my ability to cull unwanted items. In my lifetime, I had accumulated literally hundreds and perhaps several thousand trains and accessories in O, O27, standard and G primarily. In the early days of my train renaissance, I would rebuild and restore postwar locos like 675's and 2056's, or acquiring like-new items like a 2340 GG1 by word of mouth or newspaper ads. I ventured into MPC in the early '70's, and loved those colorful 6464 clones. When ennui set in, and that was frequent, I sold or traded my then "treasures" to buy something different. I also purchased a number of boxed original Lionel standard gauge sets and replaced drive wheels or detail parts as needed. At one local TCA meet in 1978, I acquired an LGB European starter set and an extra beer wagon, and that purchase set off a deep dive into those wonderful and very reliable German made trains. I was always in a kind of conundrum when I tired of my present gauge and trains, and my only reasonable choice was to cull out some to be able to afford the "next best thing"! Of course, being sub-clinical OCD, I had to choose the items on a scale of perceived "defects" in order to cull the "right" ones. Over the years, this evolved into an art form, and whether Lionel or MTH scale O, live steam G, Lionel Classics or MTH Tinplate Traditions, something eventually had to be culled to acquire some more! I have probably packed and shipped more trains and accessories than some of the smaller dealers over at least four decades! I recently made my third, and hopefully final, incursion into original LGB, and financed that, in part, by divesting all of my O gauge, save a Bachmann New York Peter Witt trolley that was a gift from my daughter. Amazingly, I also still have a three-car MTH state set I purchased in1998 and a Z-4000 I bought at the same time. In addition, have a repro 400E and a 408E and four repro 200 series freight cars. The bulk of my present trains are LGB and PIKO, with seven engines and seventeen cars. At 77, I have no immediate plans to cull anything, but never say never! LOL!
Replies sorted oldest to newest
My wife watched a show where they put everything out in the driveway and only put back the important stuff. She wanted me to go over to Lowes parking lot and get a couple guys to do the lifting. When I asked who gets to decide what is important, she said she would, so I went flying.
It all depends on your definition of 'cull'. In my opinion, 'to cull' mean to acquire more space so there is more room for more trains.
My use of "cull" was to REMOVE the old and boring, and REPLACE with the new and exciting! LOL!
My problem is that I've culled stuff that turned out later to be valuable.
I generally had to cull to afford the new, and space was always limited even with layouts at two homes in two states!
There were always some regrets, but I learned to move on!
My tastes have changed over the years, less modern and more postwar.
When I begin to run out of display space I'll look at my collection (accumulation???) and say to myself: "Self, if I saw that item today would I buy it?" If my answer is "No", that item goes up for sale to make space for something more in line with my current tastes
Since I’ve been buying trains since I was in college (I’m now going on 65), I have a lot of older “stuff” from the late 70’s - early 90’s that is stored in plastic tubs and I know I will never run/use again. Other than changing tastes (I now go for more scale equipment), when I finally built my layout, it was designed with command control in mind. So I have been sending some of the older items, no charge, to new homes where they will be loved and used. I use this to justify buying more stuff... I’m beginning to think I have a problem
In the final analysis, we all cull to a greater or lessor degree and for different reasons. Like Lou Palumbo, I have really never met (or owned) a train I did not like! ☺
Cull is a four letter word and I am shocked - yes, shocked that y’all would use language like this on a family forum! 😉
Seriously; if there is some secret to successfully culling ones collection; it has never been shared with me. 🤔
Curt