Skip to main content

65 year old, DCS, DCS Wifi & Legacy. I have the MTH wifi premium app, but I still like the remotes the best for both systems. I run MTH with DCS and Lionel with Legacy, the 2 control systems are not connected.

I am command control only, it's what got me back into the hobby when I retired at the end of 2011.

I have 90% MTH DCS (almost all PS3, only 1 PS2), 10% Legacy with some of the new Legacy CC accessories. I also really want to give DCC a try in O with my DCS stuff. My grandson has HO so DCC is a possibility there as well. 

Off to answer the other survey right after this one... Ameen, I also answered yours too.

 

Last edited by rtr12
Adriatic posted:

I'm going to take part in both (here & hoopla ) because I see them as being slightly different.

I think this ones wording  may allow more flexibility and draw of info providing the answers are in depth and hit the points. I think many, even in depth are lacking the initial thought though...

 I believe the question may be more about preferences in use, or to purchase, not neccessarly what you own.  ( O.P., Is that right Dan?)  

Some folks have all the bells and whistles, but are not necessarily using them. Others may never have tried sound or any form of command.  Where do they fall? 

54 Lunar Cycles under the Asian Purple Star charts ( ) Conventional runner by choice.  (there is a free unused dcs & tmcc waiting for years if I would just choose to take them home)

  I have tried out 4 systems of command dcc, dcs, tmcc, & radio. I don't want to use one daily. There are times I wouldn't mind it, but don't really "need it" because my hobbying is first most about simple fun and having a creative outlet. That command means one less loco... at least . The tech chase can/would undermine that at times for me. Too much like old jobs to be super fun; I need the simplicity far more to relax and be happy.

  I do own some command engines. More with just sound generation; but use them all sparingly and they wouldn't be sorely missed. (except for that whistle..... and I do use the bells (softly) more often the whistle lately, but I have no desire to put even those sounds in a xxxxT tender(t=no whistle), my silent GG-1, or silent diesels. After about 20min, the sounds are killed, but the session may last another hour or two easy.  I like the old air whistles best, no matter the sound quality of a board or realism. I also prefer the warmth of analog sound reproduction over 32bit digital CDs, mp3 is a joke. At 64bit I can't really complain though.

  A final note, I am a person with high functioning Autism. You likely wouldn't know unless I told you; just a "little" "weird", not "dumb". Unlike many "Aspie's", sounds are not often unbearable to me, especially mechanical rythms, which I usually find very soothing at any volume when consistant. ("it's your #4 intake still clicking at 3500rpm; lash it" )   Maybe that is why it isn't that appealing to me, the sounds do mask what is happening with the real mechanicals.... just a thought that it might be relevant somehow, and I just don't see it.... yet.

Adriatic, as always I value your comments tremendously!!  We are all a little weird in my estimation!  Run them however you like!! 

This is a fun post. A couple points I want to make is that I wonder for those that run conventional and command control, what is the percentage of each? I and others have mentioned conventional only on Christmas and Halloween layouts. This probably represents less than 1% of my annual operating time. In addition, I wonder how many of the above 50 demographic that were running trains like I was 25-30 years ago were thinking about running trains free of the transformer with slow speed operation? Anyway you look at it, the common denominator is fun!!!

NYC Z-MAN posted:

This is a fun post. A couple points I want to make is that I wonder for those that run conventional and command control, what is the percentage of each? I and others have mentioned conventional only on Christmas and Halloween layouts. This probably represents less than 1% of my annual operating time. In addition, I wonder how many of the above 50 demographic that were running trains like I was 25-30 years ago were thinking about running trains free of the transformer with slow speed operation? Anyway you look at it, the common denominator is fun!!!

Good point!

Comand DCS 90%

Conventional 10%

I am 51 and running TMCC engines with Legacy system and run a 1949 675 conventionally occasionally.  When I start my layout this summer, I will have a loop of conventional somewhere on the layout for nostalgia.  I am interested in some LC+ but only steam and looking for a good "cheap" Legacy engine.

I just got back in the hobby at Christmas and this is my first O gauge/scale...have HO and N in boxes in storage.

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×