Skip to main content

Good morning all.

All my life I've been told that the Central strictly used EMD F units as freight power, ordering them without steam generators. As a result, I have been forced to purchase Lionel, MTH and Williams F units with "incorrect" rooftop exhaust for said steam generators, a la the Santa Fe.

Then, watching Greenfrog's NYC Odyssey, again (My FAVORITE DVD!) I looked closely at the shot of the passing Mercury, and it hit me!

Those are F3's, in black Lightning Stripes, pulling a passenger train.

There goes 35 years of "I know the Central never used F's on a passenger train".



Is this true? Or, was this a test?

Thanks,
Mario
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Ed,

I can't tell from the pictures, but were they painted in the passenger colors?

I'm ordering some detail parts to convert some Williams F3s, into more protoypical units, and I like these pictures. They are going to be closer to late-model F3s, as opposed to these early F3s. These include:


  • Stainless side grills
  • grab irons
  • roof fans
  • wipers
  • marker lights
  • coupler cover


Thanks,
Mario
The Twentieth Century used E-units almost exclusively (particularly in the east, as the E-units rotated in and out of Harmon NY every four days) but the NYC had many other passenger trains in the transition era to pull. They had quite a few passenger F units, along with Alco PA's and FM C-liners and "Erie Builts". They also had Alco RS-3s and EMD high-nose GPs that were equipped with steam boilers for passenger service.

Many NYC F-units were re-geared for freight service as passenger service dwindled in the later fifties/early sixties.

"Diesel Locomotives of the New York Central System" by Edson/Vail/Smith is out of print, but turns up online and at flea markets and has a lot of info. Of course, the NYCS Historical Society has a lot of info too.

http://www.nycshs.org/

p.s. the F's in the original post appear to be wearing the [assenger two-tone gray of the late forties to fifties, not the black freight scheme. Look at the second car back, which is in the same paint scheme as the engines.
quote:
Originally posted by CentralFan1976:
And I look at all the Lionel, and MTH, and Williams, and all the other F Unit manufacturers that have made two-tone gray passenger F3s... and the Central only had 4!

Blows the mind!

Does anyone know why Lionel made the two-tone passenger painted F units, instead of the black Lightning Stripe?

Thanks,
Mario


Because both the Santa Fe and the New York Central endorsed Lionel's production of the then brand-new EMD F-3 in those colors.

Ed Bommer
quote:
Originally posted by Ed Bommer:
quote:
Originally posted by CentralFan1976:
And I look at all the Lionel, and MTH, and Williams, and all the other F Unit manufacturers that have made two-tone gray passenger F3s... and the Central only had 4!

Blows the mind!

Does anyone know why Lionel made the two-tone passenger painted F units, instead of the black Lightning Stripe?

Thanks,
Mario


Because both the Santa Fe and the New York Central endorsed Lionel's production of the then brand-new EMD F-3 in those colors.

Ed Bommer


...and Lionel wanted to use their new F-3s to pull trains of their new "Budd" type stainless steel passenger cars.

It is odd in these days of model train manufacturers having to pay royalties to railroads to use their paint schemes, that back then NYC and ATSF actually paid Lionel for the privilege of seeing their railroads re-created in miniature.
Eek
Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×