Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I liked it. Definitely worth watching.

 

They should do this with other railroads to remind us how vital they are. They are just there and most people do not have an understanding how difficult things could get without railroads. Railroads anywhere are quite a job to keep operating.

 

Thanks for heads up on the schedule. I missed some of the episodes.

There is a series called Extream Trains that follows differnt types of trains through out their route.  The series only lasted one season back in 2008.  The made 8 episodes.  Coal Train, Freight Train, High Speed Train, Ice Cold Express, Steam Train, Overnight Traveler, Circus Train, and  Transcontinental.  They replay these from time to time and you might find them on U-Tube.

Originally Posted by jmiller320:

There is a series called Extream Trains that follows differnt types of trains through out their route.  The series only lasted one season back in 2008.  The made 8 episodes.  Coal Train, Freight Train, High Speed Train, Ice Cold Express, Steam Train, Overnight Traveler, Circus Train, and  Transcontinental.  They replay these from time to time and you might find them on U-Tube.

This would have been a good series if somebody like Mike Rowe had been the host instead of that over the top idiot they used. The content was good, but he was so annoying that I gave away a couple episodes on DVD to a co-worker's five year old.  He has a higher threshold before he turns the TV off and walks away.

Last edited by Dieselbob
Originally Posted by Chugman:

It's a good series to watch even if you aren't into trains.  We like it.

 

Art

It's OK, but it should really be titled "Off Gridders Alaska", because it's more a story about THEM, than the railroad.  I also grow weary of EVERYTHING being down to a last second do or die crisis.  It's really a shame that the producers of these shows can't just find a good story and let it play out naturally instead of trying to interject fake hyped drama into EVERY scene and episode.  It's like the movie Unstoppable.  I honestly think the REAL story of the runaway CSX 8888 in Ohio is MUCH more interesting than Hollywood's version.  

Originally Posted by jmiller320:

There is a series called Extream Trains that follows different types of trains through out their route.  The series only lasted one season back in 2008.

Those "Extreme Trains" programs are, without a doubt, the absolute WORST TV shows about railroads that have ever been produced. They gave the entire industry a black eye. The over-excited, hyped-up host really needed to take a Valium. They got important facts outright wrong, they portrayed rank and file railroaders as idiots and generally ruined what could have been an interesting and educational series on railroading...all for the sake of hype, short attention spans and contrived excitement. Absolute trash.

 

The show only lasted a single season because after the first season was released and the shows were seen by various railroad officials, no railroad in the country would allow them back on the property. That ought to tell you something...

Both of these shows are painful to watch. The host of Extreme Trains was annoying at best. On one episode of Alaska RR. Some mother who was living out in the woods in a small cabin discovered she was out of baby formula and she had to trek through the snow and make it to the train tracks in time to flag down the speeding train. It was so cold she didn't have to wear any gloves.

Originally Posted by jmiller320:

Both of these shows are painful to watch. The host of Extreme Trains was annoying at best. On one episode of Alaska RR. Some mother who was living out in the woods in a small cabin discovered she was out of baby formula and she had to trek through the snow and make it to the train tracks in time to flag down the speeding train. It was so cold she didn't have to wear any gloves.

That is painful to read.

I hate the made up drama.  Oh, no the train won't get through.  I live up here in Alaska & I know some of the train crews.  I can tell when they are "acting" for the made up drama.  I know the scenery & trains are jumping all over the place.  They talk about trains leaving Whittier to Anchorage & I see scenery from the Seward area.  Which you won't see between WHT & ANC.  Cut out the made up drama & the off gridders & it might be an alright show.
Originally Posted by Big Jim:

I'm still trying to figure out how

quote:
It was so cold she didn't have to wear any gloves.


Just my guess but, another History Channel sensationalism, or contrived drama. Trying to make viewers think that it was "dangerously cold", yet she didn't even have gloves on. Typical History Channel artificial hype!

Originally Posted by jmiller320:

There is a series called Extream Trains that follows differnt types of trains through out their route.  The series only lasted one season back in 2008.  The made 8 episodes.  Coal Train, Freight Train, High Speed Train, Ice Cold Express, Steam Train, Overnight Traveler, Circus Train, and  Transcontinental.  They replay these from time to time and you might find them on U-Tube.

That series was OK except for the host; he was like a kid in a candy store, way too animated. It would have been better as a silent film!

Don

Originally Posted by rail:
That series was OK except for the host; he was like a kid in a candy store, way too animated. It would have been better as a silent film!

No, the series was NOT OK.

 

These programs gave the entire railroad industry a black eye. They got important facts outright wrong. They portrayed rank and file railroaders as idiots and generally ruined what could have been an interesting and educational series on railroading...all for the sake of hype and contrived, fake excitement. They were absolute rubbish.

 

The show only lasted a single season because after the first season was released and the shows were seen by various railroad officials, no railroad in the country would allow them back on the property. That ought to tell you something.

Railroad Alaska is on Discovery in the UK as well. I was hoping I would learn some more about US railroading. However it appears to be more about living out in the woods.

I did like the track gang guys in the first series but after their Forman got the push I haven't bothered watching regularly.

 

Did catch one the other week when they were shipping explosives and had forest fires....

I fell asleep so it can't have been that exciting.

 

Nick

Railroad Alaska is a "reality show" which translates to a scripted story about people that lead a highly unusual life. My son is a television producer and has done dozens of different "reality shows" and he tells us first hand what is going on.  What they strive for is conflict, fights, drama, a gross exaggeration of the ordinary and to create odd situations that have no similarity to anything real. This show like all reality shows are like watching the movies. Their sheer absurdity is what keeps people interested.

not to hijack just a comment on Fat & Furious Tommy told his customer he needed power steering on his el camino to make it safe. when he pulled the old steering box out he held it by a power steering hose. all these shows are for entertainment and to sell sponsors products. best cure for this is press the power off button and do something on the layout!

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×