Skip to main content

 

Folks, I hope I am not posting this in the wrong forum. 

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5EKawM8_IzQ

 

Here is the site detailing where these custom-made trains are manufactured, and the woman behind this enterprise. Anyone heard of her and the Great Wandering Tree donation to the museum?

 

http://www.trainlady.com/about.htm

 

Elaine Silets is an internationally recognized designer and manufacturer of Model Railroads & Garden Railways. Her work has been featured inThe Robb Report (The 21 Ultimate Gifts Special Issue), The Neiman Marcus Christmas Book and on the cover of Hammacher Schlemmer's Holiday Gift Catalogue, as well as in the lobby of The John Hancock Center in Chicago and the Christmas windows at Tiffany & Co. The company she founded, Huff & Puff Industries, Ltd., of North Barrington, Illinois, has been in business for over twenty years. She has produced Model Railroads and Garden Railways that have been featured onThe Oprah Winfrey Show, The Today Show, NBC, CNN, CBS, FOX, NBC, The Discovery Channel, The Travel Channel, PBS, as well as having appeared on the pages of Garden Railways Magazine, Chicago Home and Garden, The Chicago Tribune, The Chicago Sun-Times, North Shore Magazine and many others. She has built railroads for individuals and companies across the United States.



Building The Great Wandering Tree Layout
An introduction to the wide variety of Model RR & Garden Railways (see slideshow):  http://www.trainlady.com/demo_slideshow.htm

 

Elaine Silets intends to donate The Great Wandering Tree Layout to a Chicago-area museum. However, should the layout not be donated, it will become commercially available, price to be determined.

 

Prairie

Last edited by Prairie
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

$2,000,000 divided by 2500 sq ft = $800 per square foot.  That is about twice the going rate of professional turnkey model RR builders.  IMO, at first glance, overpriced.

 

Eight workers with a total employer's expense of $50,000 per year for each worker would only generate $800,000 in labor expense.  Maybe the rest of the price tag would pay for a plastic surgeon.

Guys, there is something wrong in the numbers. 

 

I have had to get rates for complete sceniced layouts and the going price of the folks I contacted as of last year was hovering around $375 per square foot all inclusive.

 

My example was a raw average assuming everyone worked all the time which does not happen. 

 

If it took 8 professionals two years to make that layout they all need to hop on board here and get some lessons.  You all have easily done as good or much better by yourselves mostly.

 

When these projects go together the whole crew does not work the whole time.  The pay rate also varies as to expertise.  Everyone does not pull down the higher professional pay.   A helper gets helper wages.  Lots of repetitive stuff can be done by helpers under direction. 

 

The project manager and other specialists earn their own numbers.

 

Somewhere somehow there is Hamburger Helper in the numbers.  $800 per square foot just does not line up with some of the nicest shops in the country.

 

And $2m is off the planet for what they showed us.

 

If you noted, my cost comment was IMO. we all get one don't we?  This is a free market, get whatever price you can.  However everything has a peer cost comparison.

Last edited by Tom Tee

Hmmmm....wealthy family....she's a designer...builds a "private museum" in memory of her late husband...per one of the quotes in the 2008 article, will be donated to the City of Chicago...and has an estimated value at $2MM.

Could be:

a) legitimate business deduction as a demo for her business;

b) tax deductible, charitable gift;

c) Both a & b;

d) Neither a nor b.

Jeff,

If some poor idiot actually pays 2 Million for that piece of crap,  I plan on going to a yard sale, buying the tired ol' tyco figure 8 with tunnel for a buck and selling that for 1000000% profit to said idiot.

 

 

Originally Posted by Jeff Metz:

Wow. After watching the video if that's worth 2million I'm guessing most of our layouts are worth at least 8 million.

 

Jeff

Originally Posted by Jeff Metz:

Wow. After watching the video if that's worth 2million I'm guessing most of our layouts are worth at least 8 million.

 

Jeff

 

Question is who are those folks buying these types of custom-made layouts? We know they've got money to burn, but really who are they? 

 

No doubt when you see what is on this forum, the OGR has got talent and class when it comes to its hobbyists. One has to look at the magazine also and see the beautiful layouts run after run. The past Christmas contest was proof of that. The week-end photo fun thread never ceases to amaze a non-hobbyist like myself. 

 

Prairie

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×