Skip to main content

At the risk of being philosophical, which I admit I have a tendency to do (what a gross understatement - LOL), the title of this topic is a potential justification for hunting down, and buying, whatever your favorite model train item might be at the moment, regardless of the price.

Boy, are our Forum Sponsors going to love this topic.

So, share with all your your OGR Forum friends, right here, what your #1 is. It could be a locomotive, an accessory, a structure or other item to enhance your layout, even a custom built layout, etc. Don't be afraid to dream big.

I have something in mind that I will share after at least a few of you have chimed in. Since I chose to put this topic in the Scale 3 Rail Forum, I will divulge now that the item I have in mind for myself falls within that category.

Arnold

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

As for things that actually exist: the MTH Bavarian S 3/6 4-6-2, in the K. BaySts. B. Blue livery.  I just saw and passed on one because it was scale-wheeled, it went for a surprisingly reasonable price.  Someday someone will offer up the one I can actually run.

If you want #1 out of anything possible, I guess I'd say an accurate model of the IC Green Diamond streamliner.  I already told Scott Mann I'd be the first reservation for it, at any price.

Since I have DCS and love it, and a layout with 031 curves, mine would be an MTH Proto 3 passenger set including Boston and Albany Hudson with great detail including whistle steam, swinging bell and all of the usual Proto 3 features; and Boston and Albany passenger cars with great detail including seated passengers, and the locomotive and cars would all run well on 031 curves.

I hope that the powers that be at MTH are reading this.

If Lionel gets all the kinks out of its latest tether, tether plug and receptacle for its Legacy steamers, a Legacy Boston and Albany passenger set with locomotive and passenger cars that have all the same above features would be just as good.

My current #1 locomotive that I already have is a Legacy NY Central 10 wheeler with whistle steam and with the wireless infra red drawbar arrangement between tender and locomotive, which is just fine IMO.

I also hope that those in charge at Lionel are  reading this.

Arnold

As I've stated before, I grew up in eastern Idaho during the 1950s, when Union Pacific's Yellowstone Special summer passenger train would pass through my home town on it's way up to West Yellowstone, Montana, from Salt Lake City, Utah and back. It was a night train and since my house was only about 50 yards from the track, I remember seeing it pass by.

So, I've accumulated the motive power and cars that it had and run it on my layout each summer. With Lionel having come out with its Union Pacific Legacy F7s late last year, I just had to get them to replace my TMCC UP F3s. Since the F7s are what I remember the real train using, I reluctantly paid the premium price for the double As (both powered) and a powered F7B. The real train used only an F7A MUed to an F7B, so that is what I run on the layout.

Anyway, here it is and I'm happy.

Attachments

Videos (1)
IMG_6192

I've found myself approaching the point where PRRMP54 Dave is.  It would be nice to have a Premier Western Maryland Challenger 20-3241-1  But what's the point?  It wouldn't operate on my 054 curves anyway.    In fact, I have found myself selling a few items for continuing construction of my  Blackwater Canyon Line layout in an 11x11 room.  I guess that is my big dream, to fully scenic the layout! 

i woke up with the lionel lionchief BNSF dash 8 beating me over the head to add it to my preorder with trainworld

i already have 3 other things on order with train world and that dash 8 is due september i just don't know how to explain to my god parents why i have more than one train coming to the house as my graduation present

almost a thousand bucks worth of stuff between the -

lionel lionchief fast fright set

the fast fright add on intermodal car

lionchief BNSF dash 8

lionel weather balloon defense two pack

I AM SPINELESS

If I could afford it, I'd buy a few hours labor from some of the legendary forum members, past and present, to come work on my layout with me for just one day.  Marty, Rich Battista, Tony Lash, Gunrunner J, Arnold, the list goes on.   You can all come over or down from heaven.  We'll just take a morning.  Afterwards, I'll have lunch catered in.  You have complete creative freedom, and whatever gets done in 3-4 hours stays on the layout with no future alteration.  That would be a blast!  I don't even think I could put a price on that.  Priceless.  Might just have to charge the ole Visa and move to Costa Rica soon after.  Anyway, that is my dream.  The continued fellowship and perspective of true craftsman modelers is worth more than any piece I can think of.

@Norm posted:

Arnold,

Arnold, is your family responsible for that famous red wine of yesteryear, Famiglia Cribari?

Norm

Distant relatives, Norm; last I heard, they sold out to Gallo, but I believe the Cribari name is on the bottle.

Arnold,

Not to change the subject, but I searched "Famiglia Cribari Wine" and found references including a family photo and pictures of wine bottles with the name... Now, you need a boxcar with your name on the side in large letters.

MELGAR

Okay Arnold,  you are the unofficial ( and perhaps you should be the " official") OGR Forum philosopher!!  Yet again another phenomenal topic you've come up with!  

Now I'm going to take your suggestion and dream BIG!   In the examples you gave for dreaming big, you mentioned the word " structure" which I took to mean model structure.     My BIG dream is to have a real stand alone structure around 80 ft x 50 ft. built in my back yard.  This structure would house primarily my train layout on the main floor with a loft overlooking the layout for my music studio.  Of course I'd build  the layout in the shape of the letter "E" with all edges rounded.  The back of the E ( spine ), set against the wall of the building would be 60 ft. in length and 10 ft wide and include pop up hatches for access.   The outer protrusions of the" E " would extend forward 20 ft with a 8 ft width with a large city built on each outer protrusion. One of these protrusions would host a seaport with docks, cranes, ships, tug boats, barges, etc.  in addition to the large city.  

The middle protrusion would also extend forward 30 ft with a width of 8 ft.  This section would host my home town, of Savage, Maryland.  Lots of history in this town!  The old cotton mill dates back to 1820 and was served by the B&O thru the 1960's.   The first iron railroad bridge system used by an American railroad still spans the river to this day.  The rock quarries nearby were also served by the B&O's Patuxent Branch line which  came off the B&O's Washington Division.   I'd have a master modeler build a detailed model of the cotton mill, it's steam powered powerhouse ( served with open hopper cars of coal pulled to the power house by an electric winch )  and hydro power house, and the horse race track nearby.   In addition to the mill the master modeler would build detailed models of the community hall which was constructed of  stone hauled out of the nearby river, the elementary school, the mill mangers ornate home, the company town houses, the churches, and first fire house.  Another cool fact about my hometown is that once the cotton mill closed in the late 1940's it was purchased by a Christmas Ornament manufacturing company.  The mill and all of its' mill homes were decorated/painted in Christmas colors and a reindeer castle was built.  Christmas music was played over speakers throughout the town and B&O passenger excursions brought thousands of visitors to my hometown to have a wonderful Christmas experience.  I would also model this.

Between the large cities along the spine of the "E" would be small towns, villages, and hamlets, all with their own individual charm.    One town's station would be a model of the old B&O station in Ellicott City, Md.  which was the fist railroad terminus in the U.S.  It still stands today.

There would large freight yards at each city and passenger coach yards.  Stub end passenger terminals ( one replicating B&O's Baltimore's Camden Station ... now Camden Yards where the Orioles play and the other station would be a model of Western Maryland's Hillen Station in Baltimore ).  There would be round houses at each city with working turn tables.  

A detailed model of The Thomas Viaduct Bridge will exist on this layout.  This bridge, about a 15 minute drive from my house,  was the first part of the B&O's Washington Division which spanned the Patapsco River built around 1835 ... and still carries CSX and MARC trains to this very day.  

Of course Lionel, MTH, K line, operation accessories ... as much as possible.  

The layout would run on multi levels ( with all levels connected to each other ) and include all the railroads of postwar Maryland ( 8 in all including short lines )   Each railroad having its' own level or area on the main level so these railroads could run on the layout simultaneously.

All of this set in my favorite era of railroad history ... the transition era.  ALL SCALE EQUIPMENT ...  Locomotives of the B&O would include ... 3rd Rail B&O EM 1,  Presidential class Pacifics, the Cincinattian, Mikados, Dockside, all first generation diesels. Sunset Models Capitol Limited complete set.   ......  Western Maryland Challengers, K2 Pacifics, BL2 #81 & 82, Shays, and first generation diesels. .... Pennsy GG1's, P5a and P5a modified, 2 - 10 - 4 steam locomotives, K4 Pacific,  MU cars, and first generation diesels.  A Sunset Models Broadway Limited complete set.  ... Norfolk and Western's Jawn Henry by 3rd Rail,  J class 4-8-4 both with streamlining and without, 4-8-0 Mastadon, Class A mallets, Y6b mallets.

Special custom build loco:  B&O's steeple cab electric that ran on the Baltimore Belt Line from Camden Station to Roseville, Md.  

All track Ross Custom with Ross Custom switchers.   Lionel Legacy and MTH DCS operating systems.  

The joy would come from running the trains, of course, but even more so in sharing this layout with family, friends, and folks in my community!  

Well I've got to go to bed now and hopefully dream BIG!!!  Thanks for this opportunity Arnold!

Last edited by trumpettrain
@Mark Boyce posted:

I've found myself approaching the point where PRRMP54 Dave is.  It would be nice to have a Premier Western Maryland Challenger 20-3241-1  But what's the point?  It wouldn't operate on my 054 curves anyway.    In fact, I have found myself selling a few items for continuing construction of my  Blackwater Canyon Line layout in an 11x11 room.  I guess that is my big dream, to fully scenic the layout! 

I think Mark and Dave have summed up where I am. I went from a big layout in PA to a small 8x9 in SC. I have the big steam and other items I want. Although I can’t run the bigger stuff now it’s time to spend the time and money and fully scenic the layout.

Okay Arnold,  you are the unofficial ( and perhaps you should be the " official") OGR Forum philosopher!!  Yet again another phenomenal topic you've come up with!  

Now I'm going to take your suggestion and dream BIG!   In the examples you gave for dreaming big, you mentioned the word " structure" which I took to mean model structure.     My BIG dream is to have a real stand alone structure around 80 ft x 50 ft. built in my back yard.  This structure would house primarily my train layout on the main floor with a loft overlooking the layout for my music studio.  Of course I'd build  the layout in the shape of the letter "E" with all edges rounded.  The back of the E ( spine ), set against the wall of the building would be 60 ft. in length and 10 ft wide and include pop up hatches for access.   The outer protrusions of the" E " would extend forward 20 ft with a 8 ft width with a large city built on each outer protrusion. One of these protrusions would host a seaport with docks, cranes, ships, tug boats, barges, etc.  in addition to the large city.  

The middle protrusion would also extend forward 30 ft with a width of 8 ft.  This section would host my home town, of Savage, Maryland.  Lots of history in this town!  The old cotton mill dates back to 1820 and was served by the B&O thru the 1960's.   The first iron railroad bridge system used by an American railroad still spans the river to this day.  The rock quarries nearby were also served by the B&O's Patuxent Branch line which  came off the B&O's Washington Division.   I'd have a master modeler build a detailed model of the cotton mill, it's steam powered powerhouse ( served with open hopper cars of coal pulled to the power house by an electric winch )  and hydro power house, and the horse race track nearby.   In addition to the mill the master modeler would build detailed models of the community hall which was constructed of  stone hauled out of the nearby river, the elementary school, the mill mangers ornate home, the company town houses, the churches, and first fire house.  Another cool fact about my hometown is that once the cotton mill closed in the late 1940's it was purchased by a Christmas Ornament manufacturing company.  The mill and all of its' mill homes were decorated/painted in Christmas colors and a reindeer castle was built.  Christmas music was played over speakers throughout the town and B&O passenger excursions brought thousands of visitors to my hometown to have a wonderful Christmas experience.  I would also model this.

Between the large cities along the spine of the "E" would be small towns, villages, and hamlets, all with their own individual charm.    One town's station would be a model of the old B&O station in Ellicott City, Md.  which was the fist railroad terminus in the U.S.  It still stands today.

There would large freight yards at each city and passenger coach yards.  Stub end passenger terminals ( one replicating B&O's Baltimore's Camden Station ... now Camden Yards where the Orioles play and the other station would be a model of Western Maryland's Hillen Station in Baltimore ).  There would be round houses at each city with working turn tables.  

A detailed model of The Thomas Viaduct Bridge will exist on this layout.  This bridge, about a 15 minute drive from my house,  was the first part of the B&O's Washington Division which spanned the Patapsco River built around 1835 ... and still carries CSX and MARC trains to this very day.  

Of course Lionel, MTH, K line, operation accessories ... as much as possible.  

The layout would run on multi levels ( with all levels connected to each other ) and include all the railroads of postwar Maryland ( 8 in all including short lines )   Each railroad having its' own level or area on the main level so these railroads could run on the layout simultaneously.

All of this set in my favorite era of railroad history ... the transition era.  ALL SCALE EQUIPMENT ...  Locomotives of the B&O would include ... 3rd Rail B&O EM 1,  Presidential class Pacifics, the Cincinattian, Mikados, Dockside, all first generation diesels. Sunset Models Capitol Limited complete set.   ......  Western Maryland Challengers, K2 Pacifics, BL2 #81 & 82, Shays, and first generation diesels. .... Pennsy GG1's, P5a and P5a modified, 2 - 10 - 4 steam locomotives, K4 Pacific,  MU cars, and first generation diesels.  A Sunset Models Broadway Limited complete set.  ... Norfolk and Western's Jawn Henry by 3rd Rail,  J class 4-8-4 both with streamlining and without, 4-8-0 Mastadon, Class A mallets, Y6b mallets.

Special custom build loco:  B&O's steeple cab electric that ran on the Baltimore Belt Line from Camden Station to Roseville, Md.  

All track Ross Custom with Ross Custom switchers.   Lionel Legacy and MTH DCS operating systems.  

The joy would come from running the trains, of course, but even more so in sharing this layout with family, friends, and folks in my community!  

Well I've got to go to bed now and hopefully dream BIG!!!  Thanks for this opportunity Arnold!

IMO, those of us who have layouts are all dreamers but you, Patrick, are the biggest dreamer among us.

My dream has to start with the conversion of my house.  I have a garden shed in back which, if I owned the house instead of renting, I'd convert to a two storey carriage house and the entire ground floor would be a train room.  Then, since I'm dreaming, all the raspberry pi zeroes, combined with all the wago power connectors I bought, would provide power drops and LCS junction points that would feed into (what else, we're dreaming, right?) The base three that would ship around the time my carriage house got completed.  Then I'd round everything off with more chrome plated pioneer zephyr cars for the ultimate beautiful passenger consist.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×