Originally Posted by Train6666:
Originally Posted by overlandflyer:
unfortunately it is 1:29, a poor choice for something trying to be a scale model.
Kind of a silly comment as Burls kit's are well sought after in large scale, If you look at other scales offerings, they never get it right 100% either these are really nice as with every thing Burl does.
Don't really understand why some folk knock stuff they don't' own or never seen ???????
...
regarding #1 gauge track (45mm) used to represent US standard gauge...
even if this is an accurate model in 1:29 scale, there is no getting around the fact that this scale on #1 gauge track has the largest scale to gauge error (>9%) i know of. i don't have to see anything to do the math.
ironically 3/8" to the foot (1:32), an incredibly easy to use scale, when gauged to 45mm track, has an error less than ½% but is ignored by a good deal of the G gauge crowd. MTH correctly used this scale in its #1 scale offerings, however by that time, manufacturers such as USA trains and Aristo had gotten the Garden RR community sold on the idea of "ignore the scale, if it's bigger it must be better" philosophy.
i have no doubt Burl is going where the money is.
cheers...gary