Skip to main content

"Home Grown" control solutions the answer?

 

Recent OGR forum postings have discussed "home grown" control applications using Smart Phones, Wi-Fi and "Arduino" (and similar)controllers along with custom control programs used with controllers produced by MTH, Lionel and others. It appears that a combination of control components from various manufacturers could result in a "standard" design which would allow for customized "software". The key to the direction of this control system design may depend on which manufacturers "open" their designs to the public (as recently announced by Lionel for their Legacy and Wi-Fi systems).

 

I would propose that members of the OGR forum community could form a "design team" to bring together the best ideas for moving forward rather than everyone coming up with individual home grown solutions. The best solution would be an "open" standard that included both MTH and Lionel control systems and technologies along with other third parties.

Last edited by pro hobby
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Good idea but very difficult to execute.  I do not have the expertise to do this.

 

I suspect that only a handful of forum members have the knowledge and skill to even attempt this.  Could it be brought to market even if it was done?

 

I don't see any incentive for Lionel or MTH to develop a standard system.  Of course, the MTH system will already control Lionel engines if it is set up correctly.

 

Joe

Last edited by New Haven Joe
Originally Posted by Joe Barker

 

I don't see any incentive for Lionel or MTH to develop a standard system.  Of course, the MTH system will already control Lionel engines if it is set up correctly.

 

Joe

...because Lionel , allowed licensing of the original TMCC, and they have now opened the legacy protocol as mention by pro hobby.

 

Lionel is not the brand that is" unwilling to share".

Last edited by RickO
Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×