Skip to main content

Being from the Chicago area, I have always had a great love for the following railroads common to the Chicagoland area:

Chicago South Shore and South Bend:

CSSSB

This was a local commuter service that ran from South Bend Indiana to downtown Chicago. This route serviced the far southeast side of Chicago.

Illinois Central (there is no NOISE in Illinois )

IC

In addition to providing passenger and freight service as a Class 1 railroad to Louisiana and Alabama, the IC also ran a local commuter service to various parts of the Chicago area.

and the Rock Island:

RI

This Rock Island was also a Class 1 railroad and went more southwest; providing passenger and freight service from Chicago to as far southwest as Texas and New Mexico. The Rock Island also provided commuter service to Chicago's western and southwestern suburbs.

Attachments

Images (3)
  • CSSSB
  • IC
  • RI
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Diesel:

The four that were in my current region where I've lived since '69: Frisco, Mop/Rock Island, KCS, in that order. (The Mop and Rock Island are tied for 2nd place.) Previous to that my region was KC KS/MO. However, the above were also at KC. In KC I liked all the railroads! (Still do.)

Steam:

WAY too many favorites to list. Almost all of them from the link n' pin eras.

Electric:

No thanks.

Andre

Well the pennsy is my favorite because it was so Diverse and also dominated the area where I grew up.    The famous "broadway" 4 track main is what everyone things about.    However, there were many single track lines and branches.     Southwest PA was covered with Branchlines and the PRR single and/or double track lines in the Mon Valley and the Allegheny valleys.    There is the Elmira Branch that ran from Williamsport in PA to Sodus Point on Lake ONtario in NY state.    It was a long "branch" of a couple hundred miles I think and ran through the Finger Lakes region of NY through a lot of beautiful scenery and had pullman service to Canandaigua into the 50s.

Another Favorite I learned about as studied more about RRs, is the East Broad Top.   It is by far my favorite narrow gauge line.

I also like WM, B&O and C&O.

In order:

  • CNJ
  • PRR
  • Amtrak
  • New Jersey Transit / NJ DOT
  • ATSF
  • SP
  • Conrail
  • Penn Central


ATSF and SP are a little odd on this list I realize, but I adopted those roads when I started operating trains at my 3R club, the Paradise & Pacific, in Scottsdale AZ.   

The first two I predominantly now model in 2 rail O.  However, single largest group of locomotives and rolling stock in my collection is in Amtrak in 3 rail followed by PRR in 2 rail.   

The logic?  Most of my most formative train memories were from early Conrail and 1980's era Amtrak.  Why I model CNJ / PRR from circa 1953-1957 on the Jersey shore is a story I've told one too many times on this forum so I won't repeat it.  However, these photos are worth repeating as they represent what really gets me excited in O scale trains:

_IMG2127_IMG2128

Attachments

Images (2)
  • _IMG2127
  • _IMG2128

Grew up alongside the 4 track CNJ mainline so that is my favorite.  CNJ being what it was in the 60s i got to see reading, b & o, c & o, n & w motive power so if something shows up that is interesting ill consider additions to the fleet.  Lehigh valley also had a minor presence in bayonne a few block away so that rr also gets a nod.  I never ventured the 2 miles up to the prr hump yard, wish i had, that rr had an interesting assortment of locos but cnj remains my all time favorite.

That is easy, I was born, raised, and matured in a town that back in the day was served by five class 1 roads and a bunch of subs.  We were a steel town only second to Pittsburgh in tonnage production. Those roads were the Pennsy, NYC, B&O, Erie, and the P&LE ("The Little Giant").  Plus dad was from Conway Pa. that we would pass at lease once a month visiting family.

Then in 1978 moved to Charlotte during the heart of the Claytor brothers steam excursions.  So naturally the Southern Railway and N&W came of interest. Plus in the day 40% of the N&W was owned by the Pennsy.

Ron

Hey All....

I'm lovin the bits of history you all are sharing. Just shows that though railroads may have been in the background, they played a significant part in each of our lifes. Otherwise we probably wouldn't have favorites.

I'm also surprised on the number of postings this thread is getting. I think it's very cool!

And the various logo graphics are awesome!

Logic would say that l would be most interested in the L&N and Southern as they were prominent in my home area, n. Ky., and my dad and grand-dad each worked for one.  But there was that book of Colorado railroads l would page through during my cap gun/"cowboy" era, so railroads in that frontier world appealed. They are mostly Otto Mears' roads, into Durango and Silverton.  If three rails are a stretch, modeling 3 foot with it would be jumping Royal Gorge on a motorcycle.  So l favor the roads that ran in eastern Colorado: D&RGW, C&S, R.I, M.P., CB&Q, and GW.  My first Marx 4x8, at 9, was the "Silver Creek RR" which, with NO knowledge of NE Colo, l imagined there.  So l am persistent, for in reality, the GW ran there, this decades before l heard of the GW.

My favorite is the Point Comfort and Northern Railroad.   Below from Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The Point Comfort and Northern Railway (PCN) is a Class III railroad operating in the U.S. state of Texas. The railroad operates over 14 miles (23 km)[1] of track between Point Comfort, Texas (at the Port of Port Lavaca - Point Comfort) and Lolita, Texas, where the railroad transfers cars with the Union Pacific Railroad.

PCN was purchased by the holding company RailAmerica in 2005; RailAmerica in turn was purchased by Genesee & Wyoming.

The railroad's traffic largely comes from aluminum products from Alcoa World Alumina and Chemicals as well as plastics.

PCN hauled around 12,500 carloads in 2008

The Alcoa plants have been shut down for several years.

Charlie

Last edited by Choo Choo Charlie

3A0645ED-DA18-4C10-AE38-723D957C30A0A4F7A3A9-E873-4DBD-86DD-39F4816A6BF4B46534B0-17CA-4021-A065-019022250A9DI rode the Santa Fe, Union Pacific, and New York Central when I was a kid in the 50’s and my current layout is dedicated to the ATSF road name, but my all time favorite railroad is the Cumbres and Toltec that goes from Chama, New Mexico to Antonito, Colorado. It climbs to a 10,000 ft. Elevation and the scenery is spectacular. The only other railroad to rival the Cumbres and Toltec would be the Durango and Silverton.

Attachments

Images (3)
  • 3A0645ED-DA18-4C10-AE38-723D957C30A0
  • A4F7A3A9-E873-4DBD-86DD-39F4816A6BF4
  • B46534B0-17CA-4021-A065-019022250A9D

I'm a western railroad guy. I live in Vegas, so I see a few UP diesels around town. I also ride down Cajon Pass on the way to Disneyland, so I see UP and BNSF (and occasionally a few ex-ATSF) diesels. I love the ATSF Warbonnet paint. So beautiful. I'm also a fan of the SP, WP, and D&RGW. SP had the Black Widow and Daylight paint schemes. I love those liveries, too. My layout is all BNSF and ATSF. Though PRR and CSX are also favorites, I prefer the western railroads.

The Pennsy.

Grew up alongside the mainline in NJ. Was great to see all manner of traffic. But gravitated to the branches: the Trenton ‘back road’, the Bel-Del. There’s Brunswick in my veins.

The Lackawanna.

Became fascinated with the DL&W from its interchange on the Bel-Del, and went on from there.

The Reading and Lehigh Valley also ran in my hometown, but never had much interest.

I'd say my favorite 'big' railroad would be the Great Northern; as an iron ore fan I also always liked the mid-sized (at least in terms of track miles) Missabe Road.

I guess we all judge railroads based on what we grew up with, and I grew up across the street from the Minneapolis Northfield and Southern Ry., a 'belt line' railroad that connected several big railroads south, west, and north of Minneapolis. It also connected with the Rock Island in Northfield MN - BTW re the original post, don't forget Illinois Central also served Minnesota...though just barely!

NYCRR remembered forever. My Grandfather ran steam for many years Buffalo and points East, he retired in 59'

My father died when I was young, we had rode the trains together many season's night and day on the"Water Level Route" he had a managment position and often left the babysitting of me to the diner car crew or Brakeman and often the locomotive crew if I behaved.

Buffalo on snowy nights, NYC lights, Harmon to the Park ave.tunnel, Grand Central, Colinwood yard east of Cleveland employee boarding of the 20th Century. Sneaking back to my dad in the observation car on the ESE. For some reason i loved standing in the vestibule as the Brakeman or Conductor would open the upper window approaching a station to look out, swirling snow blowing about and I could usally get a look and a smell as floor plates shifted underfoot; the sounds and the smells are always so very important to the memory. After dad died at 44 the railroad awarded all his children and my mother a lifetime pass. I used it frequently, Cleveland to NYC , and Cleveland to Buffalo.

Second place, the Great Northern, both uncles worked out of Whitefish MT. one apparently used to hunt with JJ Hill in Glacier Park regions. At age 13, I rode the Empire Builder alone from Seattle to MSP, then on the Burlington to Chicago, then on the NYCRR to Cleveland. An adventure I will never forget, trainmen looking out for me all along the way. Today I live not far from the famed Cascade division of the GNRR and love the history of the route.

Sant Fe just plain looked good, who couldnt love the Hollywood stars and starlets often feautured traveling on the Chief as she streaked across a fire colored desert at sunset.

I believe I could come to like the PRR...... however lets let Grandpa's ghost sleep.

k

East Broad Top ... My mother is from the company town that fed coal to the EBT, and I spent a                                     lot of time there at my grandparent's place

Central RR of NJ ... Though the PRR mainline went through my hometown, so did a branch of                                       the CNJ, serving industries. I would go up on my bike to watch.

Conrail ... Conrail took over that CNJ branch, becoming Conrail's Chemical Coast Secondary

Last edited by CNJ Jim

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×