Having been an LGB service tech in my past, I am very familiar with most idiosyncrasies and the occasional quirks of these otherwise well engineered German built trains! Yet, I have experienced the "squeaky syndrome" even with a 2040 RhB croc operating on LGB R3 curves (8 feet diameter)! The wheel base on the 2040 croc is fairly long and even with proper lubrication, there will be wheel squeaking on the large radius curves. My current issue is with my new LGB F-7 B&O A-B-A engines operating on LGB R2 curves (almost 6 feet diameter). The B&O wheel bases are shorter than the croc's, but even after opening all four gearboxes and lubricating all wheel axles and bearing surfaces with LGB oil and grease, the squeakiness persists! Track was previously cleaned by the PIKO track cleaning loco. Any suggestions?
"HONGZ" stands for HO scale, N scale, G scale, and Z scale.
Post your non-O scale stuff here!
Replies sorted oldest to newest
Unfortunately, in my present location, I have NO room for a larger diameter curvature.
Prototype Note: While eating dinner in our Nashville, TN town home this evening, located less than a mile from one of the branches of the CSX mainline WYE, we heard a train actually SQUEALING through the tight curvature of that trackage in spite of the rail greaser! Never, never say it is not prototypical! LOL!
PS: I do NOT presently have, nor do I plan to install, a rail greaser on my layout! LOL!
Oh, and the A Unit drive wheels have about less than an eighth of an inch lateral motion travel.
Only squeeking I ever had out of my LGB stuff was when track skates or the carbon brushes that rub the back of the wheels got a sharp edge to them and started making noise. Very annoying when they run overhead around ones living room Conversion to onboard battery power eliminated all of the power pickups, so that issue went away years ago. AD
Battery power not an option for me. May have to remove contact sliders! :-(
I have decided to remove ALL eight contact sliders on the two A units, which I believe are the cause of the squeaking. The F-7 wheel base on the R2 curves is not likely the cause of the problem, plus there is some lateral movement of the well lubricated drive wheels to offset any binding. Stay tuned.
Just downloaded the LGB pdf exploded view parts diagrams for the LGB F-7 A units so I can extract the contact sliders in an informed manner!
Every G gauge engine that I have the sliders just pull out. It becomes more involved when you run battery power because then you want to remove all the power connections to the motor.
Bob: On these A units, there is a short contact strip that connects the spring loaded slider to another strip inside the gearbox. This small strip must be removed before the slider will easily come out, without damaging the spring.
You should be careful with those no doubt that is one way they transferred track power to the motor. Much easier when running battery power you can take them all out
Alas, upon a closer inspection, the removal of the short contact tabs to the sliders proved to be more involved than previously thought as they were more completely integrated into the pickup system, so I abandoned the idea. Just cleaned and lubricated all eight sliders resulting in some reduction in the squeaking sounds.
Hey Art, let us know how you resolve this problem, as I now have a squeaky LGB engine (runs at Christmas only). I could probably start to look into this, but honestly, just not interested in opening this up right now just to look around.
Thanks for sharing your experience.
Charlie
Charlie: Will share any revelations or solutions! :-)